top of page

It Depends

6 days ago
3 min read

The tricky thing about planning your financial future is that it requires assumptions to be made. Many, many assumptions. And altering those assumptions, even just slightly, can completely change the recommended approach to maximizing your money.


Let’s explore one example: Roth conversions.


For those who aren’t aware, if you have pre-tax money sitting in an IRA or 401(k), you can decide to pay income taxes on those dollars and move them to a Roth account. The money from that point then grows tax-free, including all gains.


The downside is that you must pay taxes sooner than you otherwise would have.


But that can be worth it, especially if your tax rate is expected to increase in retirement. Paying those taxes now at a lower rate is preferable to paying higher rates on a bigger amount later.


Okay, great. So if you expect your tax rate to increase in the future, you should always complete Roth conversions, right?


Not so fast.


Let’s say life has been good to you, and you have been fortunate enough to enjoy a large IRA account, worth $2.5 million. When you turn age 73, whether you want to or not, the IRS is going to force you to take required minimum distributions from your account – essentially, the government wants its tax money. On a $2.5 million account, the government will require you to distribute about $94,000.


However, because you have been blessed with a large net worth, you plan to be incredibly generous in retirement. Instead of taking the $94,000 from your IRA, you plan to give it to charities every year. In doing so, you won’t be taxed on the money. And because the charity is a non-profit, it won’t owe any taxes, either.


You just erased all taxes on the $94,000.


If you had completed a Roth conversion on that money earlier in life and then given it to a charity, you would have unnecessarily paid more income tax than you should have.


Okay, great. So if you expect to be generous in giving money to charities in retirement, you should never complete Roth conversions, right?


Not so fast.


What if life has been exceptionally fair to you from a financial perspective, and you and your older spouse both have large IRAs? And let’s also say that at age 72, your spouse passes away, leaving you with an IRA worth $2.5 million – the exact same amount as your IRA. You consolidate those accounts, and now you have one IRA worth $5 million.


At age 73, assuming the account balance doesn’t change, you will be required to distribute about $188,000 from the account. You have no need for the money and want to give it all to charity to avoid incurring taxes. Unfortunately, you can’t. The IRS only allows you to give $111,000 a year to charities through your IRA.


That means the other $77,000 must be distributed to you, and you must pay taxes on the amount at your tax rate. Since your spouse died, you are now in the single tax bracket – not married filing jointly – which means your tax rate has spiked. Let’s say you are in the 35% individual bracket.


If you avoided Roth conversions when you were younger – and when your spouse was alive – because you would have had to pay 24% in taxes at that time, it would have been a mistake. Now you are stuck paying a much higher rate. Roth conversions would have been a wise choice in that scenario.


So, when it comes to Roth conversions – like many financial planning matters – there are no hard-and-fast rules. It depends. Change your assumptions and the best solution may change, too.


That’s what makes planning fun. And at times, maddening.

Comments


Visit

225 Main Street

Suite 100

Seneca, Kansas 66538 

Call

Tel: 785-334-4100

Fax: 785-334-4110

2018

All Rights Reserved

Our investment advisory services and investment vehicles offered:  Are Not FDIC Insured; Are Not Bank Guaranteed; May Lose Value

 

Invisor Financial LLC is a registered investment adviser with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Read our disclosures.

 

bottom of page